Volume 12 Number 3
September 2011
Editorial 98
Evaluation of noncavitated and cavitated carious lesions using
the International Caries Detection Assessment System (ICDAS II)
and oral hygiene in Thai students with disabilities
S Oranbundid, N Poomat, S Luengpailin, A Pisek, A Merchant and W
Pitiphat 99
Reliability of the BDA case mix tool for use in special care
dentistry
M Burgess, N Monaghan, M Morgan, R Playle and S Thompson 107
A pilot audit of oral health in mechanically ventilated critically
ill patients
T Lloyd, P Frost and J Rees 114
The use of applied tension to manage orthodontic extractions
in Blood-Injury-Injection Phobia: a case report
S Bhatia, C Roberts and B Chadwick 121
Dental treatment for a patient with motor neurone disease completed
under total intravenous anaesthesia: a case report
S Austin, S Kumar, D Russell, E da Silva and M Boote 124
A case report of the dental management of a patient with Sotos
syndrome
S Mohammed Asif and S Waghray 128
Solitary median maxillary central incisor in two healthy siblings:
case report
R Barcelos, P Tannure, J Farinhas, E Kahn and R Gleiser 133
Case report: management of unerupted incisors in a patient with
Angelman Syndrome
M Storey, J Kewley and V Brookes 136
Paradigm shifts and the ICF model
A paradigm is a set of assumptions, concepts, values and practices
that constitutes a way of viewing reality. The dominant paradigm
in health has undergone a massive shift in the last 20 years. The
ubiquitous medical model that revolved around disease management
was revolutionised by concepts of quality of life and the behavioural
aspects of health. Further evolution has reached beyond the realm
of the individual into the domain of the social determinants of
health (Marmot & Wilkinson, 1999) and the concept of universal
human functioning (Bickenbach et al., 1999). In the domain of disability,
this change has been particularly palpable in the WHO system of
classification (Stucki & Grimby, 2004).
The original International Classification of Impairment, Disability
and Handicap (WHO, 1980) described a linear model with a disease
or disorder leading directly to impairment then disability and handicap.
The current International Classification of Functioning (ICF: WHO,
2001) abandons the negative connotations of impairment and handicap.
It is a complete classification of human functioning in terms of
body function and structure, individual activity, and participation
in society. These dimensions are modified by environmental and personal
factors. Disability is thus not considered an illness but is defined
according to how a person fulfils his/her normal social role within
a given environment. It is universally applicable to all persons,
with or without a declared disability, and critically, recognises
the major influence of environment on human function.
Why is this paradigm shift so important in the context of disability
and oral health? We are all aware of the major inequalities in oral
health experienced by persons with disability. Many of our efforts,
as a profession, have been directed at providing services to reduce
the overwhelming volume of unmet need in terms of disease management.
It is time we stopped dealing solely with disease and started to
address the wider determinants of inequality. The ICF provides a
model around which to conceptualise this change. It allows us to
perceive our patients, not in terms of medical diagnosis or DMF,
but in terms of how well they are able to eat, drink, talk, participate
in meals, and more importantly, what factors in their social environment
impact on this ability to function successfully. It is only by identifying
these influences, at individual and population levels, that we may
reduce inequalities in relation to the social determinants of health
and in relation to the prevention of oral dysfunction and disease.
So how can special care dentists help to reduce inequalities through
paradigm shift? The ICF is an enlightening gift to those wishing
to improve oral health for all disenfranchised groups in society.
ICF Core Sets are already well recognised as practical tools used
widely in other disciplines (Stucki & Grimby, 2004). The future
development of ICF Core Sets for Oral Health could enable:
Collection of reliable, reproducible epidemiological data, comparable
between local and international communities
Clinical assessment for therapeutic and research purposes, based
on a patient-centred model
Recognition of the specific oral health problems and needs of subgroups
of the population and identification of the functional and environmental
determinants of oral health for different groups
Identification of environmental aims in therapy and prevention
Improvement of communication and collaboration between medical and
social professionals, patients and policy makers
Provision of arguments for the patient-orientated perspective in
the negotiation and planning of oral health services
Assessment of oral health services and treatment outcomes, including
public health measures, prevention and health promotion
Development of dental curricula from a holistic perspective.
It is my belief that the International Association for Disability
and Oral Health (iADH) is facilitating this paradigm shift by endorsing
the ICF model. Paradigm shifts are discreet, implicit and intangible
but they can rapidly and radically revolutionise thinking and thus
action, particularly in terms of attitude, policy, legislation and
service provision. Education and dissemination of knowledge hold
the key to this process and the iADH have recognised this priority.
The associations action to develop core curricula in special
care dentistry based on the ICF is an important step in encouraging
change.
For further information regarding the development of core curricula
for special care dentistry visit www.iadh.org or contact: scipe@iadh.org
For further information regarding the project to develop ICF Core
Sets in Oral Health contact denise.faulks@u-clermont1.fr
References
Bickenbach JE, Chatterji S, Badley EM, Ustün TB. 1999. Models
of disablement, universalism and the international classification
of impairments, disabilities and handicaps. Social Science and Medicine
48: 1173-1187.
Marmot MG, Wilkinson RG. 1999. Social Determinants of Health. Oxford
University Press, Oxford, UK.
Stucki G, Grimby G. 2004. Applying the ICF in medicine. Journal
of Rehabilitation Medicine 2004; (44 suppl): 5-6.
World Health Organisation. 1980. International Classification of
Impairments, Disabilities and Handicaps (ICIDH). WHO, Geneva, Switzerland.
World Health Organisation. 2001. International Classification of
Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF). WHO, Geneva, Switzerland.
Dr Denise Faulks, BDS, PhD
CHU Clermont-Ferrand, Service dOdontologie, F-63000 Clermont-Ferrand
and Clermont Université, Université dAuvergne,
EA 3847, BP 10448, Clermont-Ferrand, France
Evaluation of noncavitated and cavitated carious lesions using
the International Caries Detection Assessment System (ICDAS II)
and oral hygiene in Thai students with disabilities
Supatra Oranbundid BDH MPH1,2, Nusara Poomat DDS3, Somkiat Luengpailin
DDS PhD4, Araya Pisek DDS3, Anwar T Merchant DMD ScD5 and Waranuch
Pitiphat DDS MPHM MS ScD3
1Faculty of Graduate Studies, Khon Kaen University; 2Sirindhorn
College of Public Health Khon Kaen; 3Department of Community Dentistry,
Faculty of Dentistry, Khon Kaen University; 4Department of Oral
Biology, Faculty of Dentistry, Khon Kaen University: Khon Kaen,
Thailand. 5Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, University
of South Carolina, SC, USA
Abstract
Aim and objectives: Epidemiological data concerning oral health
status of individuals with disabilities is sparse and most studies
do not include the assessment of noncavitated lesions. This study
aimed to evaluate noncavitated and cavitated carious lesions and
oral hygiene status of students with disabilities in Khon Kaen,
Thailand.
Design: Participants included 285 students aged 6-15 years with
visual impairment, hearing impairment or physical disability who
attended special needs schools in Khon Kaen. Dental caries was examined
using the International Caries Detection and Assessment System (ICDAS
II). Oral hygiene was assessed using Silness and Löe plaque
index (PI).
Results: Almost all students had at least one noncavitated or cavitated
lesion (97.1% in primary and 95.4% in permanent dentition). When
considering only cavitated lesions, the prevalence was 90.6% in
primary and 69.1% in permanent dentition. The overall mean (±standard
deviation) dmft, dmfs, DMFT and DMFS scores were 6.3±4.6,
17.6±16.1, 9.7±6.1 and 16.0±11.0, respectively.
The mean number of noncavitated surfaces (3.4±3.4) was lower
than that of cavitated surfaces (11.8±13.5) in the primary
dentition, but the opposite trend was observed in the permanent
dentition: noncavitated (12.3±8.5) and cavitated (2.7±3.9)
surfaces. Most carious lesions remained untreated in all groups.
The overall PI score was 1.4±0.4 demonstrating a moderate
level of oral hygiene.
Conclusions: Students with disabilities experienced high levels
of both noncavitated and cavitated lesions. Effective preventive
measures are required to improve the oral health of this disadvantaged
group.
Reliability of the BDA case mix tool for use in special care
dentistry
M Burgess1, N Monaghan2, M Z Morgan3, R Playle3 and S Thompson4
1Learning and Scholarship Group, Cardiff University School of Dentistry;
2Public Health Wales, Temple of Peace and Health, Cathays Park;
3Applied Clinical Research and Public Health, Cardiff University
School of Dentistry; 4Learning and Scholarship Group, Cardiff University
School of Dentistry, Heath Park, Cardiff, UK
Abstract
Introduction: The British Dental Association (BDA) have developed
a case mix tool for measuring patient complexity to aid commissioning
and evaluation of special care services. The aim of this study was
to explore examiner agreement when using the case mix tool.
Methodology: All 143 dentists who had attended the launch and training
for the BDA case mix tool were invited to take part via email. Ten
hypothetical scenarios of patients with complexities were created
for this study and provided to participants. Using the case mix
tool guidelines, all scenarios were scored on six different criteria.
These scores were compared with gold standard answer scores to measure
the reliability of the tool. Internal consistency among participants
scores was also assessed. Data on prior experience of using the
case mix tool and of special care dentistry was collected.
Results: Of the 41 dentists who replied to our invitation 26 agreed
to take part. Cronbachs alpha scores for the six criteria
ranged from 0.37 to 0.76 with the lowest for communication and the
highest for oral risk, highlighting a wide variation in internal
consistency. Average Kappa scores ranged from 0.31 to 0.71 indicating
a range in agreement with the gold standard. The lowest level of
agreement was for oral risk and the highest for co-operation. Those
with prior experience of the tool and of special care dentistry
did not demonstrate improved agreement with the gold standard when
compared with those without experience.
Conclusion: Dentists show significant variation when assessing patient
complexity using the BDA case mix tool. This has implications for
the reliability of the tool among those who use it. Further development
of the criteria, validation, training and regular use would improve
the validity and reliability of the BDA case mix tool.
A pilot audit of oral health in mechanically ventilated critically
ill patients
T E Lloyd1, P J Frost2, M P Wise2 and J S Rees3
1Locum Registrar in Maxillofacial Surgery and 2Consultants in Critical
Care Medicine, University Hospital of Wales: 3Professor of Restorative
Dentistry, Cardiff University Dental School, Cardiff, UK
Abstract
Aim and objectives: There is increasing awareness among Intensivists
that poor oral hygiene may be associated with ventilator associated
pneumonia in intubated patients. The aim of this pilot audit was
to assess the oral health status of mechanically ventilated, critically
ill patients. The adherence of intensive care nursing staff to local
guidelines for the delivery of oral care was also assessed.
Design: Ten patients admitted to the intensive care unit (ICU) were
examined during an eight-week period. Oral health on admission was
assessed using DMFT scores, a plaque index, BPE and periodontal
probing depth. Oral health was also assessed daily following oral
care by nursing staff up to the point of extubation.
Results: All patients showed evidence of poor dental health. Half
of the sample had untreated decay and seven patients had evidence
of moderate to severe periodontal disease. Simple oral hygiene measures
carried out by ICU nursing staff generally improved oral health.
Conclusions: This audit highlighted the poor oral health status
of patients on admission to the ICU. It also highlighted the vital
role of nursing staff in delivering daily routine oral hygiene measures.
The use of Applied Tension to manage orthodontic extractions
in Blood-Injury-Injection Phobia: a case report
Shannu Bhatia BDS MDS MFDS RCS (Eng) M Paed Dent RCS (Eng)1, Caroline
Roberts2 and Barbara Chadwick BDS, MScD PhD FDS RCS (Ed)3
1Paediatric Dentistry Unit, University Dental Hospital; 2Paediatric
Psychology, University Hospital of Wales; 3Applied Clinical Research
& Public Health, School of Dentistry, Cardiff University; Cardiff,
Wales
Abstract
Blood-injury-injection phobia (BIIP) is characterised by a strong
tendency to faint when exposed to phobic stimuli. Patients with
BIIP often exhibit dental anxiety and may deliberately avoid dental
treatment. The dental anxiety in BIIP does not respond to conventional
techniques as just relaxation increases the likelihood of fainting.
It is important for dentists to be aware of this condition since
it requires specific management.
Dental treatment for a patient with motor neurone disease completed
under total intravenous anaesthesia: a case report
Sarah Austin BChD Hons (Leeds) MJDFRCS (Eng)1, Sajith Kumar FRCA2,
David Russell MSc (Manc) BDS (Lond) FDSRCS(Eng)3, EJ da Silva MB
ChB DA (Zim) FRCA (UK) PGCME (Birm)4 and Martin Boote MSc (Birm)
FDSRCS (Eng) BDS (Lond)
1Specialty Trainee in Orthodontics, Newcastle Dental Hospital;
2Specialist Registrar, Birmingham School of Anaesthesia; 3Consultant
in Restorative Dentistry and Special Care Dentistry, Birmingham
Dental Hospital; 4Consultant in Anaesthesia, Royal Orthopaedic Hospital
Foundation Trust, Birmingham; 5Senior Dental Officer, Heart of Birmingham
PCT
Abstract
A 78-year-old male patient presented to the Birmingham Dental Hospital
for dental treatment. His management was complicated by amyotrophic
lateral sclerosis (ALS) a form of motor neurone disease, with associated
inability to protect his airway due to bulbar involvement in the
disease process. His dental treatment was managed successfully as
a day case with total intravenous anaesthesia (TIVA) by target control
infusion of propofol and remifentanil, aided by monitoring with
bispectral index monitoring (BIS). No non-depolarising muscular
blocking drug was used. Intubation was performed solely under propofol
and remifentanil. The procedure lasted 150 minutes due to the extent
of dental treatment required and the patient was discharged home
120 minutes after the completion of the procedure. A discharge this
early has not previously been reported. No complications resulted.
A case report of the dental management of a patient with Sotos
syndrome
Shaik Mohammed Asif1 and Shefali Waghray2
1Assistant Professor,Department of Oral Medicine and Radiology;
2Post Graduate,
Department of Oral Medicine and Radiology; Sri Sai College of Dental
Surgery,
Vikarabad, India
Abstract
Sotos syndrome, a rare disease of cerebral gigantism, is characterised
by overgrowth, advanced bone age and a typical facial appearance
with mild to severe learning disability. This paper reports a case
of an 18-year-old male patient with Sotos syndrome and rare association
of optic nerve atrophy who, unaware of his underlying condition,
reported to our dental clinics with a complaint of spacing between
his lower front teeth. The purpose of this case report is to review
the diagnostic characteristics of Sotos syndrome, emphasising the
importance of a multi professional dental intervention in combination
with active family participation.
Solitary median maxillary central incisor in two healthy siblings:
case report
Roberta Barcelos DDS MSD PhD1, Patricia Nivoloni Tannure DDS MSD2,
João Alfredo Farinhas DDS MSD2, Evelyn Kahn MD MS3 and Rogerio
Gleiser DDS MSD PhD2
1Department of Specific Formation, Federal Fluminense University,
Nova Friburgo, Brazil;
2Department of Pediatric Dentistry and Orthodontics, Federal University
of Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil; 3Genetics Ambulatory,
Martagão Gesteira Pediatric and Puericulture Institute, Federal
University of Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil and Pediatric
Genetics Ambulatory, Antônio Pedro University Hospital, Fluminense
Federal University, Niterói, Brazil
Abstract
A solitary median maxillary central incisor is an unusual dental
finding and may be associated with short stature, growth hormone
deficiencies, syndromes and chromosomal abnormalities. This paper
describes two cases of the absence of a maxillary central incisor
affecting both dentitions in two healthy siblings. No reports were
found in the literature similar to this rare situation. This anomaly
can be considered a predictor of holoprosencephaly in the next generation
and affected individuals may require a long term evaluation by a
multidisciplinary team.
Case report: management of unerupted incisors in a patient with
Angelman Syndrome
M Storey BDS (Hons) MFDS RCS (Edin)1, JV Kewley BDS, FDS.RCS(Ed)
M Dent Sci (Paed) (Lvpl) Dip Con Sed (Nwcl) MSND RCS(Ed) Specialist
in Paediatric Dentistry1 and V Brookes BDS MSC FDS RCS (Ed) FDS.RCS
(Eng) DDPH RCS (Eng) MSND RCS (Ed)2
1Senior Dental Officer in Special Care Dentistry & Sedation;
2Specialist in Paediatric Dentistry
Abstract
This paper describes the dental care provided for a 9-year-old
patient with Angelman Syndrome, who presented with delayed eruption
of the maxillary permanent left central and lateral incisors, and
dental caries. The importance of effective communication with colleagues
and parents of the patient is highlighted, along with the benefits
of taking a holistic approach to patient management. Patients with
learning disabilities present the dental practitioner with a wide
range of management issues. An understanding of a patients
disability and how this impacts on treatment planning and provision
is fundamental in providing quality care for patients.
JDOH home
BSDH home
|